Skip to main content

What Makes a Great Team

What makes a great team? After decades of studying, building, and coaching teams, we believe it comes down to three things: top talent, the right basics, and genuine community.

Mark Miller
Co-Founder, Lead Every Day

What makes a great team? After decades of studying, building, and coaching teams, we believe it comes down to three things. Great teams attract top talent, they master a short list of team basics, and they build genuine community (a level of care for one another that sets the best teams apart).

Our answer took shape over many years. In the late 1980s, Mark’s boss at Chick-fil-A, Dan Cathy, who would later become CEO, walked into his office with a one-line assignment: “Make us a team-based organization.” He turned and walked out before Mark could respond.

That assignment shaped the next two decades of Mark’s career. After more than ten years of discovery and practice, Chick-fil-A asked him to capture what they had learned, and the result was his book, The Secret of Teams.

Since then, the two of us have trained thousands of teams across business, education, sports, health care, ministries, and more. What follows in this article is what we’ve learned, along with ideas you can try with your team this week.

Where Is Your Team Today?

Over the years, we’ve seen teams fall into three groups:

  • Underperformers – use a lot of time and energy with little to show for it.
  • Good Teams – produce solid results, though few people would call the experience inspiring.
  • High Performance Teams – create and sustain elite results, often far beyond what good teams achieve.

Team experts Jon Katzenbach and Douglas Smith found that the typical person can expect to be part of a truly exceptional team about once in a career. Once!!

Although this finding may be true, that’s not a good enough answer for us.

We’ve spent decades helping leaders beat those odds, and our goal is to help you, the reader, learn from the time we’ve spent accomplishing this task.

One way to see where your team is currently standing is to picture a performance curve. As a team matures, its impact grows. Now, it’s important to mention that maturity and time together are two different things. A group that has worked side by side for ten years can still be early on in the curve, and it’s up to you as the leader to help your team grow the proper way.

Take a look here at the different stages of teams:

The five stages of teams: Work Group, Pseudo Team, Potential Team, Real Team, and High Performance Team

Look closely at the Pseudo Team stage. When a group first tries to work as a team, results often dip before they rise. This makes sense because new responsibilities are assigned, new terms are adopted across the board, and it takes time to formulate the systems required to grow into a healthy team.

Unfortunately, many teams give up at the Potential Team stage. They’ve added meetings and action items, but their results look about the same as before. People are quick to get frustrated at all the extra work that’s going into this, but this is precisely the moment that calls for vision and leadership. Teams are so close to the breakthrough when they hit this stage, but without the proper leadership, they never break through the wall that’s in front of them.

If you are lucky to find yourself on an exceptional team, you’ve likely landed in the realm of real teams – high performance teams. Once you’re here, expect the standards to be raised across the board.

The little things are done with care
The large tasks are delegated to those capable
And the speed at which everyone moves is on another level

So, now that you know the breakdown of where teams live, where would you place your team on this curve today? As we like to say, you have to start where you are, but you don’t have to stay there forever.

Now how do you become a great team? Great question, here’s what we believe:

1. Great Teams Attract Top Talent

The team with the best players has the best chance to win. That’s why we see talent as the foundation of a High Performance Team.

Mark learned how much this matters one night in a meeting with Chick-fil-A’s incoming president and head of operations. For years, the company had surveyed its key leaders about their biggest challenges. That year, for the first time, “finding and keeping people” rose to the top of the list, and Mark left the meeting with the job of helping solve that problem.

Before building a team to tackle this, Mark visited a veteran Operator known for attracting great people. The Operator listened to what Mark shared with him, then proposed a better question:

“How do you attract and keep the right people?”

That question reshaped the work entirely. Mark’s team searched for six months and could not find research that answered this question, so they commissioned their own. The study that was conducted by Mark’s team surveyed, interviewed, and held focus groups with more than 7,000 people, ages 15 to 65 and up, from all 50 states.

This study found that Top Talent looks for three things:

  • A Better Boss. They want to be led well, and for the most talented people, that is a condition of staying.
  • A Brighter Future. They want to know how a role will stretch them and prepare them for what comes next.
  • A Bigger Vision. They want to contribute to something bigger than themselves. This held true across the age groups in the study.

You must understand that talented people have options, and a great team gives them good reasons to stay.

2. Great Teams Master the Basics

Some of the most useful team practices are also the simplest. They’re easy to learn and free to use, so a leader can start with them right away.

We teach seven Team Basics, and each one helps a team move up the curve.

Team Basic #1: Create Role Clarity

When Peter Drucker was asked about the most important decision a leader makes, he answered, “Who does what.” In our work, unclear roles sit behind many of the team problems we’re asked to help solve.

One of our clients, the owner of a plumbing company, told Randy about the day he decided to “unload my truck.” He had been working in the field beside his two technicians, and he realized he was working in his company without leading it.

So he moved his tools to the garage, kept a small bag for emergencies, and started driving to the office. The company grew from four people to more than 50 employees, and he points to that one decision about his role as the turning point.

Team Basic #2: Establish Team Purpose

Teams do their best work when they know why they exist. Try this at your next meeting: ask each person to write down their answer to “Why does our team exist?” on a 3×5 card, then read the cards aloud (without interjecting your own opinion).

Mark once used this exercise with the senior leaders of an organization that was founded more than 100 years ago. He collected 12 thoughtful answers, and each one was different.

(P.S. It’s hard to lead a team well if each senior leader has a separate purpose)

Teams outperform individuals when people pursue a common goal. A shared purpose gives them that goal. So be sure to establish your team’s purpose, and agree on it.

Team Basic #3: Set Team Goals

We suggest three to five team goals. Look at past performance and what’s ahead, and invite the team’s input. We’ve been surprised by how often teams set higher goals than their leaders would.

Mark saw this with a nonprofit team he led. They chose to double their usual attendance for an event, a far bolder goal than he would have set, and they reached about 90% of it.

That result was well beyond their normal output.

Our rule of thumb is to aim for a goal with roughly a 50% chance of success.

Team Basic #4: Build Your Scorecard

A scorecard tracks the handful of numbers that tell you whether your team is healthy. Fewer is better, and three to seven is a good place to start.

A senior leader at Southwest Airlines once told us they had narrowed their scorecard from 44 key metrics to eight. When we noted that eight still seemed like a lot, he smiled and said they really had three primary metrics, with five supporting numbers.

If clarity is kindness when it comes to business, then you can bet that less on your scorecard is more results you can count on being in your favor.

Team Basic #5: Conduct Great Meetings

If you want to see what a leader can do, watch them run a meeting. We think of meetings as a leader’s short game, like chipping and putting in golf.

A study from Atlassian found that 72% of meetings are ineffective. The encouraging part is that a few habits can turn meetings into some of the most productive hours on your calendar.

Appoint a facilitator and send the agenda ahead of time. Give about 75% of the agenda to performance: reviewing the scorecard and action items, solving problems, and recognizing people. Close each topic by deciding who will do what by when, and write it down.

Prepare the plan.
Present the plan.
Pivot where needed.
Prioritize your action items.

Then go do the work!

Team Basic #6: Solve Problems Together

A team brings more perspectives to a problem than any one person can. Many teams spend their meeting time on updates because they haven’t yet learned a problem-solving method.

For system or process problems, we use five steps:

  1. Define the problem.
  2. Identify the likely root cause.
  3. Brainstorm solutions for that one root cause.
  4. Create a plan of action: who will do what by when.
  5. Monitor results.

When the issue involves one person’s performance, we ask four questions:

  • Do they know what is expected of them?
  • Do they have the skills to do it?
  • Do they have the resources they need?
  • Do they understand the consequences of missing it?

When it’s abundantly clear what the issue is, it’s much easier to craft a plan of action to help the individual or the team get past the problem that’s in front of them.

Team Basic #7: Improve Decision-Making

Team decisions can move quickly when people know how a decision will be made. A leader has four options:

  • Command: the leader decides.
  • Consultative: the leader asks for input, then decides.
  • Consensus: the team reaches a decision the whole group can fully support. Use this one sparingly, because it takes the most time.
  • Delegated: the leader hands the decision to someone else.

Be honest about which one you’re using. If you’ve already made the call, name it a command decision. In our experience, five minutes spent teaching these four types of decision making can save a team a lot of time.

Let’s move onto the last piece of the puzzle behind great teams.

3. Great Teams Build Genuine Community

The basics can take a team to Real Team status. Reaching high performance takes one more ingredient: community.

Mark’s team discovered this by accident many years ago. They had hired a consulting firm focused on team skills and built several strong teams. During one session, the consultant sat in on a meeting to give feedback. Afterward, she said she wasn’t sure what to make of the odd thing they did at the start of their meetings, but it seemed to be helping, so they should keep doing it.

The “odd thing” was a few minutes for each person to share a personal update.

Through it, the team learned that teams carry two agendas. One is the task agenda, the work you’re charged with, and the other is the social agenda, which is about the people on the team and their lives at work and beyond.

Later, the team found language for what they were seeing in Katzenbach and Smith’s book The Wisdom of Teams. The authors described rare teams whose members cared deeply for one another and for the work, and they treated those teams as a happy accident. Mark and his team set out to build that kind of care on purpose, and they called it community.

We describe community as a place where people:

  • Know Deeply. They know one another’s stories. As someone once told us, “It’s hard to give up on someone once you know their story.”
  • Serve Willingly. Serving one another becomes normal. Coach Lou Holtz told Mark he ended each practice by asking his players how they could serve one another. The requests ranged from needing a ride to getting help studying for a math test.
  • Do Life Together. They show up for one another in the highs and the lows, at work and beyond.

Community grows with time on the agenda, meeting after meeting. In our experience, it’s the multiplier that separates good teams from High Performance Teams.

We know that this information can be a lot to take in at once. So let’s focus on where to start if you’re not quite past a Pseudo Team or Potential Team status.

Where to Start With Your Team

Pick one step to try this week:

  • Ask the 3×5 card question at your next meeting and compare the answers.
  • Take five minutes to teach the four decision types.
  • Open your next team meeting with a short personal check-in.

They sound simple, because they are. But I promise you these steps are more effective than you could possibly imagine.

Improving team performance is one of the three disciplines in our Lead Every Day Operating System. To go deeper on moving your team up the curve, explore our team performance resources or learn how we work with teams.

We’re grateful your team has you to show them the way. Best of luck on your leadership journey.

Mark & Randy, the LED Team.

Mark Miller

Co-Founder Lead Every Day
Bestselling author and longtime Chick-fil-A leader, Mark spent his career building leadership systems at scale. His books include The Secret (with Ken Blanchard), Culture Rules, Talent Magnet, and Win Every Day.
Free assessment

How strong is your leadership?

Most leaders rate themselves 30 points higher than their teams do. Find out where the real gaps are.
  • Score on the five fundamentals
  • See where to focus next
  • Built on 250,000+ leaders
No cost to take it.

Build a team that collaborates every day

Coaching, workshops, and the Lead Every Day Operating System help your leaders turn ideas like this into daily habits across the whole organization.
250K+Leaders equipped
25+ yrsOf leadership research

Leadership skills in your inbox.

Always get the latest from the Lead Every Day Team

By clicking Sign Up you’re confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.

Keep reading

Help People Win

When Leaders Think Family Instead of Team I’ve be…

A Simple Idea With Huge Potential

A Simple Idea to Accelerate Your Team’s Performan…